Primitive Obsession – The code smell

https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/primitive

Programming languages divide their types mainly into two categories.

  • Primitive types (A built-in types like string, boolean, int, decimal…)
  • Objects (class/function): User-defined types using class-based/prototype-based objects.

A primitive data type is a data type for which the programming language provides built-in support. Example: number, string, boolean, date and so on.

There are situations when developers should represent their idea/concept using user-defined types (Abstraction or encapsulation).

Whereas they choose to use primitive types (inbuilt int, string…) to represents the concept.

“Talk is cheap. Show me the code.” ― Linus Torvalds

Consider the above API for scheduling meetup.

If you observe carefully, all the parameters: topic, description, date, location id, and max participants when they stand together represent the concept/idea called meetup.

Almost all the data types are primitive types (Built-in types: string, int, DateTime and so on).

Problem?

Overutilization of these primitive types to solve a problem makes the code more verbose/procedural and logic to deal with them is scattered.

Solution:

Since all method parameter stands together to represent the concept called Meetup.

Here, we could group all these parameters together to represent the idea/concept called meetup. So, introduce an object to gather these data values.

Upon replacing data values with an object API would look like:

This is how the API should have been. However, the developer chooses to go with all built-in types (segregated). IMO, this overutilization of primitive types in almost all cases can be treated as an obsession about primitives which can be called a primitive obsession.

I have explained only one scenario and there are other scenarios too.

Dattatraya Kale

Aspiring agile software craftsman, clean code, polyglot, in love with different programming paradigm. I am on a never-ending journey towards mastery of software.

Leave a Reply